Home & GardenPreparing & Cooking

Is The Dinnerly Meal Delivery Service At $5 A Serving Worth It? One Mom’s Review

Photo of author

By Candida

Family meal planning around our house usually involves the same go-to meals — a general repeat of the ones we know and like. Maybe, you should consider adding the Dinnerly menu to your weekly family meals.

A typical week in our household typically includes meals like:

  • Spaghetti
  • Steak
  • Salad and broccoli
  • Frozen pizza
  • Chinese take out
  • Pizza take out
  • Maybe a 2 for $20 meal at Chili’s restaurant

I actually love to cook and prepare meals for my family. But sometimes it just doesn’t always work out for a variety of life reasons — especially with a toddler.

After I’d heard nothing but great reviews about the meal delivery service called Dinnerly from my mother and sister-in-law, it peaked my interest as a chance to switch up our family meal menus.

My sister-in-law sent me a link for a free box, so I decided to sign up and give it a try.

What Makes The Dinnerly Menu Different

Here are some things that make the Dinnerly meal delivery menu different:

Wide variety and customization:

  • Large selection: Dinnerly offers a wider variety of recipes than most meal kit services, with over 100 different options each week.
  • Dietary filters: You can easily filter recipes by dietary restrictions like vegetarian, vegan, low-calorie, kid-friendly, low-carb, gluten-free, dairy-free, and one-pot meals.
  • Customization: Many recipes allow you to swap proteins for a personalized experience, like using chicken instead of beef.
  • Saver recipes: They offer “Saver” recipes at a lower price point, making the service more budget-friendly.

Other unique features:

  • Market add-ons: You can add grocery items like desserts, breakfasts, and pantry staples to your order.
  • Easy-to-follow recipes: The recipes are designed to be simple and achievable, with clear instructions and minimal prep time.
  • Transparency: Dinnerly discloses all ingredients and nutritional information on their website.

Ultimately, the best meal kit service for you depends on your individual needs and preferences. However, Dinnerly’s large menu, customization options, and budget-friendly pricing make it a strong contender for many people.

Why My Family Loves The Dinnerly Menu

Dinnerly delivers all the fresh ingredients needed to create 3 weeknight meals — direct to my doorstep — for $5 a serving plus $8.99 shipping.

Their whole gimmick is to deliver simple recipes and fresh ingredients for affordable weeknight cooking amongst the busyness of our lives.

Basically, they try to keep each recipe down to 6 ingredients and 6 steps — with a fresh, fully cooked meal in 30 minutes or less.

Each week, they give me 6 different meals to choose from and I have to narrow my selection down to 3. This is great, because it means menu options — especially since I know there are certain things my husband won’t eat.

How Dinnerly Menu Compares To Other Meal Delivery Kits

CompanyVarietyCustomizationPriceDietary OptionsUnique Features
DinnerlyWide (100+ recipes)Swap proteins, dietary filtersBudget-friendly “Saver” optionsVegetarian, vegan, low-calorie, kid-friendly, low-carb, gluten-free, dairy-free, one-potGrocery add-ons, easy recipes, transparent ingredient info
HelloFreshLargeLimitedStandard pricingVegetarian, low-calorie, pescatarian, family-friendlyDiverse recipe options, high-quality ingredients
Blue ApronMediumLimitedPremium pricingVegetarian, diabetic-friendlyUnique and seasonal recipes, focus on quality ingredients
Home ChefSmallerExtensiveCustomizable meal plansVegetarian, pescatarian, keto, paleo, gluten-freeFlexible meal options, add protein boxes
SunbasketMediumLimitedPremium pricingVegetarian, vegan, paleo, gluten-free, Mediterranean, diabetes-friendlyOrganic and sustainable ingredients, focus on clean eating
Marley SpoonMediumLimitedStandard pricingVegetarian, pescatarian, low-carb, gluten-freeQuick and easy recipes, chef-curated menus

With Dinnerly, at $5 a serving, I feel this is a great price point to get all of the fresh ingredients delivered to me. A meal delivery service like this makes it easy to create a new variety of family meals.

I really love that there is no commitment too. I can cancel anytime, or skip a week — if we are going to be out of town.

It’s a truly flexible subscription which allows me to pick & choose the meals I want up to 2 months in advance.

Dinnerly Serving Sizes

The Dinnerly meals are available in either a 2-serving or 4-serving box.

I decided to start with the 4 serving box for a few reasons — even though it’s just the 2 of us, plus baby:

  • Baby is eating solid foods and joins in our meals.
  • I like to have leftovers for lunch the next day.
  • I also give the dogs some of our leftover food mixed in with their dry dog food.

My sister-in-law subscribes to the Dinnerly 4 serving box and she has a family of 6 (2 adults, 4 kids). She says that she incorporates a salad of some kind to each meal and always has more than enough food.

A Few Things I Really Like About Dinnerly

I’ve found the Dinnerly recipes are relatively simple to prepare, although they do require some minimal prep — such as washing and chopping fresh produce. But I like to prepare my own food anyway.

I love how all the recipes take 30 minutes or less.

All the meal kits come with good quality ingredients — such as fresh produce, grass-fed beef, and antibiotic-free chicken.

Your Dinnerly box arrives on the day of the week and the timeframe of your choosing.

If you’re curious about the amount of packaging, the Dinnerly box is made from paper sourced from sustainably managed forests — so it’s easily recyclable. (They use insulated material which is made of brown paper and newspaper.)

The food that they ship is prepared to stay cold for up to 30 hours — if you happened to miscalculate your delivery time.

The ice packs are made of 98% water and 2% super absorbent polymer, which is non-toxic & non-hazardous. The bags can be cut open and recycled after the ice is melted and drained.

TIP: We like to keep a few of the Dinnerly ice packs in the freezer to use later — like in the cooler when we’re traveling!

What’s Included In The Box & What’s Not

To keep their costs affordable, Dinnerly does not include recipe cards in the box — like some of the other meal kit delivery companies do.

So I print out my upcoming recipes from the Dinnerly website. I may even start a 3-ring binder to keep all the recipes for future meal inspiration.

But you can easily view the recipes on any device as you’re cooking – if you don’t want to print the recipes.

Dinnerly does not provide these items — which are used in many recipes:

  • Kosher salt
  • Fresh ground pepper
  • Olive oil
  • Eggs
  • Condiments

However, they do tell you in advance exactly what you will need to prepare the meal.

They also have suggestions on some of the recipes — such as garlic bread or a salad to take your meal to the next level.

My Only Advice…

I would strongly advise anyone who is trying the Dinnerly meal delivery service to:

  • Read all the recipe directions first.
  • Have everything that’s required for the meal ready to go before you start.
  • Watch everything as it cooks (especially in the oven).

I imagine all oven temperatures are slightly different. As an example, even though I followed the instructions, I burnt the tortilla shells at 8 minutes even though the recipe calls for 10 to 15 minutes. Luckily, I had extra tortillas on hand to save the meal.

The Bottom Line

I received a free Dinnerly box — but not to write this review. Nor am I affiliated with Dinnerly. I’m just a MaMa sharing my experiences and trying new things. I did get a link to share with others and to gift a free box to 3 friends after my first delivery. (Everyone who signs up for Dinnerly gets this.)

I think Dinnerly does a great job with their word-of-mouth marketing by incentivizing their customers to keep giving a box. After all, that’s how I signed up and became a customer.

So far, I’m enjoying creating a new variety of meals for my family. I always look forward to seeing which meals are on the upcoming week’s menu. I definitely encourage you to give it a try and spice things up with your family meal planning.

In case you were wondering if other people think the Dinnerly meal delivery service is a good thing, check out how fast they grew:

Dinnerly launched July 2017 on the West Coast — serving California and most of Washington, Oregon, Nevada, Utah, and Idaho. By September 2017, Dinnerly rapidly expanded to include most of Texas, Illinois, Georgia, Wisconsin, Oklahoma, Colorado, Iowa, Louisiana, Arkansas, Indiana, Kentucky, Tennessee, North Carolina, Virginia, Florida, New Jersey, Connecticut, Rhode Island, Maryland, Massachusetts, Washington D.C., Pennsylvania, and New York. Today, Dinnerly is available nationwide, covering 93% of the U.S. population.